Buy Nothing Day, an international protest
against unbridled consumerism, was marked on Saturday in more than 60
countries, including Switzerland.
speaks to the Swiss event’s organiser, the founder of a Buy Nothing
Christmas initiative and asks a retail expert whether it’s all just a
waste of time.
“The philosophy is to object to
the current trend, dictated to us by most Western governments, that a
good citizen is one who buys a lot,” said Pietro Majno from the Swiss
Growth Objection Network, which is organising events across the country.
The first Buy Nothing Day was organised by Canadian anti-consumerist
organisation Adbusters in 1992 and was held for the first time in
Switzerland in 2008.
“In Geneva there will be a stand where people can barter things without
using money,” Majno told swissinfo.ch. “They are encouraged to exchange
something immaterial, for example knowledge, good experiences – you
could exchange a list of your ten favourite books for a list of ten
favourite films or walks.”
Majno, a doctor, says he could exchange advice on losing weight or
keeping fit with someone who would give him, say, a recipe.
“We want people to reflect on the role of money in our society, in
which people think that if something doesn’t have a price, it doesn’t
have any value.”
Majno denies meeting resistance
from businesses or retail associations. “It’s more condescension. They
say the main argument against [such events] is that if people don’t buy
anything, unemployment soars,” he said.
“We’re told we’re just happy dreamers who are completely unrealistic. I
object to this, because for me the unrealistic thing is living outside
our budget as humans, causing damage to the environment and society.”
Critics also argue that people simply make their purchases the
following day. Does Buy Nothing Day actually have any effect?
“In practice, on the amount of things that people buy on that day, no,”
“But it makes them think about their relationship with money. Ideas
like this are gradually becoming not just the eccentricities of a few
intellectuals – more and more people are realising that there is no
alternative to decreasing the use of resources and energy, and that
must involve a complete rethinking of our relationship with objects.”
Dimitri Wittwer, a marketing
expert at Bern University, says that to estimate retailers’ losses, one
has to differentiate between two effects: the immediate loss on the day
itself and the change of the customers’ attitudes towards purchases.
“The former is not what really hurts retailers because their loss will
only result in a decrease in spontaneous purchases – customers can
easily purchase what they really want and need the day after,” he told
“The latter, however, can cause a change in the attitude towards
consumption and so have a negative impact on sales in the long run.”
For Wittwer, Buy Nothing Day is a symbolic way of criticising
capitalism. “I don't think it achieves a change in Western customers’
attitudes. It offers consumers an easy way to help make the world
better and it gives them a better conscience.”
No ho ho
Earlier this month a study by
accountancy firm Deloitte showed that while most Europeans will be
cutting costs this Christmas, the Swiss will be spending 1.2 per cent
more than last year on presents, food and going out.
According to a parallel study by Ernst & Young, the Swiss budget
just for gifts was now SFr301 ($300) a head, up from SFr267 last year.
Aiden Enns took the “buy nothing” concept a step further and in 2001
launched a campaign with fellow Mennonites – a Protestant faith with
historical roots in Switzerland – for a Buy Nothing Christmas.
“I’m disturbed by a society-wide agreement to over-shop, especially in
December. In Canada and the United States, shopping has become a
leisure activity and an obsession, which is legitimised in our
gift-giving rituals,” the Canadian founder of Geez magazine told
“When I was working at Adbusters in 2001, I saw how successful the Buy
Nothing Day campaign was, and thought it should be rolled out for the
whole Christmas shopping season,” he said.
“Also, because I’m a Christian, I wanted to make a statement that not
all Christians celebrate excessive consumption in the name of their
religion. It’s absurd to shop at toxic levels in the name of the child
that was born to bring peace to the world.”
Solidarity and hope
Enns acknowledges that despite
his views he still buys something almost every day.
“This astounds me. So on Buy Nothing Day I can pay attention to this
contradiction and strengthen my resolve to live differently,” he said.
“Plus, it gives us a sense of solidarity and hope, that consumerism
need not be the reigning social practice. Maybe care for our neighbours
and the earth’s resources can be our orientation. I hope so.”
Thomas Stephens, swissinfo.ch